I was with my partner for 7 years. He didn’t technically live with me, as he worked and lived regionally. We saw each other mainly on weekends (rent was not paid to me, but he did contribute financially and was generous). I thought our ‘long-distance’ relationship worked, I thought he thought so also. However, he was always emotionally unavailable and a non-communicator. I would try to get him to open-up to me on many occasions. I tried to break up with him a number of times but he would say he would do better and open up, I would stay, and of course this pattern repeated. He assisted financially in the renovation of my house. Which we always said we would then move to his farm and build a life in the country together. I always intended to pay him back if/when we broke up. About a year before we finally broke up our intimacy had dropped to non-existent. When I finally called it over, he didn’t fight for me this time. I sold my house so I could pay him back for the renovations, I paid him $80,000. When I think I probably should have paid him have the profits instead, which was $60,000. I have recently found out, over a year later after we broke up, that he was having an affair. With a woman married to his friend and co-worker, whom they have two children. The affair started around the same time as our intimacy had stopped. He and her had gotten pregnant and had an abortion around Christmas time, two months before we broke up. I’m heartbroken. Now that this has come to light and he was betraying and lying to me for over a year, I have confronted him and asked him that had I known, I would not have given him the full amount. I have asked him for $20,000. He believes I have no right and he owes me nothing. He and her are still together by the way. What do you think?
7 Replies
You willingly gave money, so no you can’t state you want it back now.
I would have given him 0 to begin with; and made him fight for it - but it’s always the lessons we learn after the fact.
Time to move on with what you have, and not dwell on the past.
I think walk away for your own sanity and just let it all go. Yeah you were done dirty but doesn’t mean his hard earned money shouldn’t be returned. Just move on and focus on your own happiness. Legal action has nothing to do with your mental anguish and has no weight on the outcome in that respect.
No, leave him alone for your own sanity and move on. The sooner he’s nothing to do with you, the happier you will be able to become.
Also, you paid him what you agreed to pay him. And it looks a bit like spite, and I fully understand he’s a shitbox but his shitfuckery doesn’t change the deal, that you’d pay him for doing up your house. I doubt the deal was ever to pay him the profit, you proved it yourself by already making the payment.
Let it go to the bottom of the ocean along with him and move on.
I would say you owe him nothing. But check with a lawyer.
This will cost you, too in fees.
It sounds like you've got a lot to sort through but he paid you to renovate a house he wasn't living in and you sold at a profit. You reimbursed him for just the costs.
Anything less is robbery and asking for money because you're hurting and want revenge isn't right.
'The only winners are the solicitors'. I didn't quite understand this until I've recently had a couple of family & friends go through cases.
The cost, time & stress is mind blowing. You might not win. You'll end up with a massive bill that'll eat your savings. The cost will far outstrip anything you get back.
I'd move on & learn the lesson about protecting your assets in future.
No don’t waste more time on him. To fight for that money would only cost you more money without likelihood of success as if you’ve paid him back the amount he contributed then hold your head high that you’ve repaid the debt owed. He could have taken legal action for the amount he contributed and then you’ve got legal costs on top of the amount also.
I'm sorry you are going through this.
I would leave it. As much as it really sucks. It's not worth it.
Karma will bite him one day. You know you're a good person and did the right thing morally. He can't say the same.